I want to start off by saying I am not
denying that Michael Jordan is one of the best players to ever play the game
and that what he did for the NBA and basketball was incredible in itself. I
know that many see him as clearly the best player of all time but I hope that I
can provide enough evidence to sway that opinion. So let’s begin: Is MJ really
the best?
For many years it has almost been
blasphemous to say anyone other than Michael Jordan is the Greatest
Basketballer of All Time. Even if you ask non- NBA fans who the greatest is
they will always tell you MJ despite them not even watching a game. This is
because the media have told us time and time again that he is untouchable and
clearly the premier player of the NBA. This myth is wrong and it is unfortunate
that MJ is synonymous with being the best player of all time just because
that’s what we have been lead to believe.
Michael Jordan had an illustrious career
with many awards these include:
6-time NBA Champion
5 MVP awards
10-time scoring champion
3-time steals leader
14-time all star
6-time NBA Finals MVP
1-time NBA Defensive player of the year
11-time All-NBA
9-time All-Defensive
NBA Rookie of the year
And 2 Olympic Gold Medals
He averaged 37.1 ppg in one season and 35ppg in another with
a career average of 30.1 ppg in his career and 33.4 ppg in playoffs. His well
known highlights include the dunk from the free throw line, the Flu game and
‘The Shot”. While the numbers, the awards and accolades are all incredible we
are talking about being the best player to ever play the game. This ‘award’
isn’t about stats though if it were then the best would be Wilt Chamberlain or
Oscar Robertson, it’s not about Championships either otherwise Bill Russell
would be the Greatest of All Time. To analyse the true GOAT we must take into
consideration the era, the impact on their team and the way the public perceive
the player based on what the media and NBA tells us.
Impact
on team
Michael Jordan entered the NBA in 1984 and
won Rookie of the Year. The Bulls however went an abysmal 38-44 and lost 3
games to 1 in the first round of the playoffs. He is supposed to be the GOAT
yet couldn’t even manage a winning record in his opening season? It’s not like
he didn’t have help either he had Woolridge who averaged 22.9 PPG and 5.6 RPG
and Quinten Daily averaging 16 PPG.
In his second year Michael was injured for the majority and
the team went 30-52 he did however play in the playoffs and had a game where he
scored 63 and the Bulls were still swept in the first round.
His third year despite his 37 PPG average they
STILL had a losing record 40-42 (5th in the Central Division) and
again were swept in the first round of the playoffs! Interestingly he only
averaged 4.6 assists this year and yet no one labels him a ‘ball hog’.
He was 1-9 in the playoffs until Pippen
arrived. 1987 was when Scottie came to the party and in that year the Bulls
improved to a 50-32 record (2nd in the Division) and lost in the
Semis.
Surely though when Michael retired the Bulls
took a big hit right?
In 1992-93 they had a 57-25 record and won the
championship then MJ retired for the first time. If you lose the Greatest
Player of All Time you would assume you’d at least drop 15 games and probably
not make the playoffs. But surprisingly the Bulls’ record only dropped 2 games
to 55-27 and they lost in seven games in the Semi finals. Only a 2 game drop
off after losing the supposed GOAT how do other stars stack up in this
category?
Bill Russell: When he retired the Celtics went from 48-34 to 34-48
Bill Russell: When he retired the Celtics went from 48-34 to 34-48
Wilt Chamberlain: When he retired the
Lakers went from 60-22 to 47-35
Oscar Robertson: The Bucks went from 59-23
to 38-44
Larry Bird: When Larry was injured and only played 6 games the Celtics went from 57-25 to
42-40
Magic Johnson: The Lakers went from 58-24
to 43-39
Take a closer look at this season without
MJ, you would assume that Pippen and Grant would’ve had a worse shooting
percentage, as the defenses would now focus on them lets look at the stats.
92/93 With MJ
Pippen: 18.6 PPG 47.3 FG%
Grant: 13.2 PPG 50.8 FG%
92/93 With MJ
Pippen: 18.6 PPG 47.3 FG%
Grant: 13.2 PPG 50.8 FG%
93/94 Without MJ
Pippen: 22 PPG 49.1 FG%
Grant: 15.1 PPG 52.4%
Furthermore the 9 players who played both
these seasons collectively improved their FG% from 48.2% to 48.6%. This is
unusual because you would assume with all the double teams MJ demands that he
would be able to find open players for great looks!
How about when he came out of retirement late in the
following season? The Bulls actually slipped 8 games and again lost in the
Semis.
What about the start of their careers how
did the other greats fare in comparison to Michael?
Larry Bird entered the league in 1979 in
that year Boston improved from a 29-53 record to a 61-21 record. That’s a 32-win
difference in only his rookie year and a turn around from last in the Atlantic
division to first. They lost in the Eastern Conference Finals that year and won
the Championship in his second year!
Kareem Abdul Jabbar improved Milwaukee from
27-55 to 56-26 in his rookie year and won the championship in his third!
Oscar Robertson improved Sacramento Kings
from 19-56 to 33-46 in his first year
Wilt in his first full season with the
76ers improved them from a 40 win team to a 55 win team and won the title with
them in the next season
In Wilt’s rookie year with what was then
known as the Philadelphia Warriors the team improved from 35-37 to 49-26 and he
averaged 37.6 PPG and 27 RPG in only his rookie season.
Magic Johnson improved the Lakers from
47-35 to 60-22 and won the title in his rookie year.
Clearly Michael did NOT have the biggest
impact on his team even when on the Wizards for his final 2 seasons they did
not make the postseason.
The
ERA
"We could not have won 70
games playing against 1980's teams."
-Dennis Rodman, starting power forward for
the 1995-96 Chicago Bulls
Michael had his success in the 90’s winning
all his six rings in this decade. In this era the league
expanded added 6 more
teams over 8 years, which meant stars were scattered all over the place and not
playing together. The only competition for MJ was really Julius Erving, Clyde
Drexler and Dominique Wilkins. They were the best
guards at this time and none of them were real rivals like Magic and Larry. In
the 80’s you needed 3-4 Hall of fame players to compete, in the 90’s the Bulls
had 2 Hall of Famers and Dennis Rodman, who was already a Defensive Player of
the Year and a 2 time NBA champion, in a time where most other teams had one
HOF player if they were lucky. Other eras had more concentrated talent in each team.
‘There’s nothing comparable to that quality (of the
80’s) competition at the top for these Chicago Bulls’ – an NBA commentator at
the time
Compare that to who Kobe Bryant has had to
face and beaten in their prime: Allen Iverson, Tracy McGrady, Lebron James,
Dwayne Wade, Paul Pierce, Kevin Durant, Vince Carter, Manu Ginobili, Ray Allen
not to mention he has had to defend Deron Williams, CP3, Russell Westbrook,
Rajon Rondo and more who were way more athletic and better than most of the
guards in MJ’s time.
In the 60’s there was Wilt, Oscar, Elgin
Baylor, Bill Russell, Jerry West all superstars that competed against each
other. There were also less teams
meaning they had more concentrated talent in each team during this era.
Kareem had to go up against players like McHale, Olajuwon, Barkley, Robert Parish, Patrick Ewing.
Kareem had to go up against players like McHale, Olajuwon, Barkley, Robert Parish, Patrick Ewing.
The teams in the 90s were all spread out whereas
in other eras the teams have been stacked with multiple stars going against
each other.
Michael Jordan was also a terrible 3-point
shooter. Most people don’t know that in the 1994-95 season the NBA made the
3-point line closer. These are the 3-point FG% numbers for MJ before this
season:
84-85: 17.3%
84-85: 17.3%
85-86: 16.7%
86-87: 18.2%
87-88: 13.2%
88-89: 27.6%
89-90: 37.6%
90-91: 31.2%
91-92: 27%
92-93: 35.2%
The NBA didn’t change it back until the 97-98 season in which
MJ shot 23.8% from 3-point range.
"I
think our best teams could handle them, we had Kareem in the middle, he always
made the difference for us."
Earvin "Magic" Johnson on whether or not
his Lakers of the mid to late 1980's could defeat the 1995-96 Chicago Bulls.
The
Media
“The media now has anointed Michael
Jordan the greatest of all time. Is he greatest of all time? No, I don’t think
he is.” –Oscar Robertson
The NBA under David Stern excelled
financially and the number of viewers dramatically increased. Mainly because of
the intelligent marketing put behind Michael Jordan. He created so much revenue
for the NBA and for Nike. Two years after he signed with Nike, they recorded $1
billion dollars in profit. We’ve heard terms such as ‘Be Like Mike’ on the
Gatorde commercial raking them a lot of publicity and money or ‘His Airness’
this is because at this time the NBA only promoted one player during this time,
there was never anything like this in any sports the amount of attention just
given to a single player and you could tell on the court that other players
were starting to get sick of it.
‘You couldn’t win any points if you said something bad
about him’ –Andrea Kremer Chicago Bureau
The movie Space Jam made 450 million
because MJ was in it. He brought in 10 billion dollars worth of revenue for the
NBA- as long as he was making money the media were going to keep hyping him up.
‘When it comes to Michael Jordan we were in some
sought of national denial, everybody made money through Michael Jordan’ –Media
Personality
They changed the rules to help MJ win and
changed the whistles to make sure that if he wasn’t going to win he would still
win. Even now he still makes money
off the Jordan brand, so the media keep pushing him and now we are left to
cling to a manufactured image.
"They are trying to sell
today's game, not the game from the 1960's, 70's or 80's."
-Wilt Chamberlain on the NBA in 1996
No other player has been so heavily marketed. |
“ESPN began distributing sports programming outside
the United States in 1983” (Encyclopaedia Britannica 2011). Before this most games were only
shown locally not even nationally. So Michael Jordan would have been one of the
first players the world had seen on screen actually play. He was the
headline during this period
so everyone got a glimpse of him. Jordan became the first player to have his face
on a Wheaties box, the Brand went to Coca-Cola, Chevrolet, Gatorade and
McDonald’s. It’s simply a case of the media telling us what we want as
consumers. We see Jordan as this enigma because his career coincided with the
boom of consumerism and television expansion. Imagine if Kareem, Magic, Wilt or
Oscar Robertson were televised worldwide or if they had this much media
exposure, everyone would be preaching that they were the Greatest Of All Time.
The media has a lot of power and in this instance it was used to enhance
revenue by hyping up Michael Jordan.
Not to mention that the NBA changed the
rules so Jordan could seem even better than what he was such as the shortened 3
point line, hand checking rules and new rules regarding illegal defenses.
"If Michael was here right now, I would say to
him: When you are so great that the league tries to change the rules in an
attempt to stop you then you can claim you are the best ever.
Every rule change I have seen during your career has been meant to enhance your
game."
-Wilt Chamberlain
Extra
Specific Examples
In 1991 Magic Johnson destroyed Michael
Jordan in Game 1 of the Finals.
In Games 2-5 Pippen guarded him instead and the
Bulls won the series keeping Magic pretty quiet.
Kobe scored 55 on him in 2003.
Game 5 1988 playoffs Eastern Conference
Semis
MJ scored 2 points in the 4th quarter and his team
gets eliminated- but you never hear about this do you?
Game 5 1989
Jordan scores 18 points, only 1 point in
the fourth, Detroit take the lead and eventually the series.
After the struggling years for Jordan where
he couldn’t beat the Bad Boy Pistons there were many rule changes making it
harder to play physical- basically helping Jordan to win and earn more money
for the league.
The Reggie Miller and MJ fight proved the
biased culture towards MJ. Reggie was thrown out yet MJ threw a punch yet not
only wasn’t ejected he wasn’t even given a foul! The Pacers coach showed some emotion and
then was given a technical. Incredible.
1993 ECF Bulls vs Knicks
One of the most fixed series in the NBA, down 2 games to zero the refs came to the rescue, calling phantom foul after phantom foul.
One of the most fixed series in the NBA, down 2 games to zero the refs came to the rescue, calling phantom foul after phantom foul.
“They knew who they were marketing for the business…. You look back and look at the teams who can make the money for the league. Michael Jordan or Patrick Ewing? No question it was Michael Jordan …he got more calls’ –Charles Oakley
1998 season
Interestingly MJ was 35 this season and
lost some athleticism. He had his worse FG% year at 46.5 % so how then does he attempt
more free throws than he has since 1989 (10 years) when he was much younger and
could get to the rim way easier? Because the refs gave him a lot of calls to
help him out. In the first round of the playoffs he was clearly struggling but
with a little help from his friends the Nets’ best defenders were in early foul
trouble and MJ made 23 free throws in this game. He scored 39 points and 23 of
these were free throws.
It is sad how even young NBA fans today who
barely have seen a Michael game automatically believe he is the best because
the media makes it seem that way.
“We protected him more than I’d like to admit’ –Media
personality
It’s just not true. The perception is that
he is a perfect character and saint-like well we’ve seen the fight with Reggie how about what
he said to Cartwright after a bad night:
“Look, if you ever do anything like that again, you will never play basketball again because I will break both of your legs."
“Look, if you ever do anything like that again, you will never play basketball again because I will break both of your legs."
In practice Perdue placed a hard
screen on MJ, well Michael didn’t like that and punched him in the face! He also punched Steve Kerr in the face as
well. Seems like a perfect role model doesn’t he.
Without Pippen Jordan went 1-9 in
playoffs
Without Jordan Pippen went 11-15 and
made the West Conference Finals. He was older and out of prime too.
Here are some more interesting comparisons
Kareem without Magic (10 seasons)
Kareem without Magic (10 seasons)
Championships: 1 MVPs: 5 NBA Finals: 2 Best
record in NBA: 3
Bill Russell without Bob Cousy (6 seasons)
Championships: 5 MVPs: 1 NBA Finals: 5 Best
record: 2
MJ without Pippen (5 seasons)
Championships: 0 MVPs: 0 NBA Finals: 0 Best
record: 0
First 3 years comparison
Kareem:
Championships: 1 MVPs: 2 NBA Finals: 1 Best
Record: 1 Playoff record: 23-12 Losing records: 0 Scoring titles: 2
MJ:
Championships: 0 MVPs: 0 NBA Finals: 0 Best
Record: 0 Playoff record: 1-9 Losing records: 3 Scoring titles: 1
My
Greatest of All Time List
1.
Kareem Abdul
Jabbar
6 Championships,
6 MVPs. Played at an elite level for 20 years, which is an extremely hard thing
to do. Kareem made the defense worry, he was incredible especially with what he
did for Milwaukee. He has 2 scoring titles, 1 rebound title and 4-time block
leader. He averaged 24,6 PPG and 11.2 RPG over a 20 year career with his best
season averaging 34.8 PPG and 16.6 RPG. His career numbers are lower because
his production obviously declined as he neared the age of 40.
2.
Wilt Chamberlain
He could easily be number 1. There has not been a player that has dominated like Wilt did. He had a better vertical than MJ and Lebron, an elite track athlete and could reportedly bench more than Shaq. The 60s were a more physical era than when MJ played and superstars weren’t given the benefit of the whistle and the rules were changed to prevent Wilt from dominating so much but they didn’t work! He was an incredible athlete; over his 14-year career he average 45.8 minutes played per game! No center was able to run with him, in this time the games were like track meets, quick paced and a lot of scoring. He averaged 50.4 PPG in 1961-62 with 25.7 rebounds, has seven scoring titles, 11 rebounding titles and lead the league in assists one year (MJ has never done this and he is a guard!) He was a part of the famous Laker team that won 33 games in a row and went up against Kareem in the 70s. He has 119 50+ point games to MJ’s 29, he has the most points in a game (100) and rebounds in a game (55). He has 6 of the 9 70+ point games in the NBA (MJ has zero). A 4x MVP and 2x Champion. Oh and he has the only 20-20-20 game EVER.
He could easily be number 1. There has not been a player that has dominated like Wilt did. He had a better vertical than MJ and Lebron, an elite track athlete and could reportedly bench more than Shaq. The 60s were a more physical era than when MJ played and superstars weren’t given the benefit of the whistle and the rules were changed to prevent Wilt from dominating so much but they didn’t work! He was an incredible athlete; over his 14-year career he average 45.8 minutes played per game! No center was able to run with him, in this time the games were like track meets, quick paced and a lot of scoring. He averaged 50.4 PPG in 1961-62 with 25.7 rebounds, has seven scoring titles, 11 rebounding titles and lead the league in assists one year (MJ has never done this and he is a guard!) He was a part of the famous Laker team that won 33 games in a row and went up against Kareem in the 70s. He has 119 50+ point games to MJ’s 29, he has the most points in a game (100) and rebounds in a game (55). He has 6 of the 9 70+ point games in the NBA (MJ has zero). A 4x MVP and 2x Champion. Oh and he has the only 20-20-20 game EVER.
‘In terms of greatness MJ has to take a backseat to The Stilt’
-Kareem
3.
Michael Jordan
You can’t
deny MJ’s greatness although the media helped enhance a lot of it. He was
incredible and did change the NBA for the better. But he was not as valuable to
his team as the other greats were. Michael was a great defensive player but it
has been blown out of proportion, he did get owned a couple of times by Magic
and other stars, and against Kobe. He played 15 seasons most of them in a weak
era under expansion and the rules were changed to help him win whereas Kareem
played 20 at a high level and Kobe has already played 17 and continuing to
dominate. Why do we never hear of Michael’s short comings as I explained
previously yet stars of today are put in the firing line: Kobe’s rape case,
Lebron quitting on Cleveland and having a flopping reputation. Yet MJ is made
out to be some sort of saint that can do no wrong.
4.
Kobe Bryant
Kobe will
surpass MJ when it is all said and done take away the media hype off of MJ and
they are basically the same player except Kobe is a better 3 point shooter. I
have never seen someone take over games like he does. He doesn’t just score the
game winner or game tier, he scores the last 4 big shots of a game and he makes
the impossible shot seem possible. Look no further than the game this season vs
Toronto. He hit 3 ridiculous threes and won them the game or against Portland
in his early days. There are numerous occasions where Kobe has just grabbed the
game by the throat and won it. He had an 81-point game, a 62 point game in
three quarters and averaged over 40ppg in back to back months the only other
player to do that was Wilt (MJ has never averaged over 40ppg in a month). He is
also a great lockdown defender and takes the opponents best player in the final
quarter or against Boston he took Rondo for most of the series and he usually wins
these matchups. Unfortunately he spent most of his prime with Smush Parker,
Kwame Brown and Luke Walton for starters. If he had of left at this time I feel
he would’ve won way more championships but the fact that he didn’t shows his
tenacity and adds an interesting aspect to his legacy. He has been able to put
up incredible numbers even in his 17th season in the league. No one
has produced like him at this time in his career not even Kareem.
Common misconceptions:
Kobe is a ball hog: Kobe averaged 2.5 more assists per game at this point in his career than MJ did
Common misconceptions:
Kobe is a ball hog: Kobe averaged 2.5 more assists per game at this point in his career than MJ did
Kobe has worse
stats than MJ: Kobe wasn’t a starter in his first two seasons so his career
averages are brought down
Kobe was
carried by Shaq: If you actually believe this your kidding yourself, check our
Kobe Shaq article.
Kobe only has
one MVP: He deserved a lot more; he was robbed a few times in 06 and 07
Kobe has missed
the most shots out of anyone in the league: In his prime he had to play
alongside the players I mentioned before. Who do you want shooting Kobe or
Smush?
5.
Magic Johnson
We’ve talked
enough about Magic he had an incredible influence on the Lakers and deserves
every accolade he gets. 5X Champion 3X MVP. Played in probably the hardest era
of basketball.
6.
Larry Bird
Close to Magic. 3X Champion 3X MVP see earlier for his
incredible impact on the Celtics.
7.
Oscar Robertson
Oscar Robertson
is one of the most well rounded players ever. In only his first season he
averaged 30.5 PPG 9.7 RPG and 9.7 APG. He averaged a triple double over his
first five seasons combined! Not to mention he was two inches shorter than MJ.
The only reason Oscar doesn’t have more rings is because his teams always lost
to Chamberlain or Bill Russel’s teams. He also got stuck playing with small
market teams and had little help until he paired up with Kareem and won a ring.
If he was in the 90’s or had a better team he would have won more than MJ. He
also made players around him better unlike Jordan and lead the league in
assists 6 times. Wayne Embry was an all star 5 times out of 6 years that they
played together and Embry is a 6 foot 8 undersized center. If we are picking
the Greatest Players based on talent and skill Big O would be ahead of MJ.
Side note: For Lebron to be even considered in the discussion he would have to surpass Big O and I don’t see that happening. People say Lebron is better than MJ because of his better all around game yet why don’t they talk at all about Oscar when his game was the most complete ever? I’ll tell you why it’s another case of the media doing its job for revenue!
Side note: For Lebron to be even considered in the discussion he would have to surpass Big O and I don’t see that happening. People say Lebron is better than MJ because of his better all around game yet why don’t they talk at all about Oscar when his game was the most complete ever? I’ll tell you why it’s another case of the media doing its job for revenue!
8.
Bill Russell
11 championships and clearly one of
the best rebounders/ shot blockers ever. Why do I put Big O ahead of him even
though they were in the same era? Well Big O was always on poor teams except
for Milwaukee with Kareem where he won a ring. Big O was chosen 9 times for
All-NBA first team compared to Russell’s 3 and was a much better scorer than
Bill. The Celtics team Bill had was stacked.
The Big O is the best all-around player the NBA has ever seen. |
Who is the Greatest Of All Time?
References:
http://www.aussiehoopla.com/why-michael-jordan-is-not-the-greatest/